Wildlines Archives
Volume II, Number 36
September 8, 2003
A publication of the State Environmental Resource Center (SERC) bringing you the most important news on state environmental issues from across the country.
 
 
NEWS FROM THE STATES:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Bottle Bills
NJ Anti-Sprawl Rule Delayed to Close Loophole
ALEC’s Resolution on Climate Change
 
Colorado Study Confirms Deer-to-Deer Spread of CWD
Chittenden County, Vermont Launches 'No Idling Campaign'
WI Pushes for Construction Waste Recycling
Mourning Doves under Fire in Midwest
Inter-State Summit on Missouri River Set
Trend Shows City Centers Changing
Chesapeake Bay Foundation Seeks Binding Compact from Governors
Florida Not Collecting Polluter Fines
Western States Brace for West Nile Virus
Bottle Bills
"Bottle bills" are laws that require a minimum refundable deposit on beer, soft drink, and other beverage containers in order to insure a high rate of recycling or reuse. Deposits on beverage containers are not a new idea. The deposit-refund system was created by the beverage industry as a means of guaranteeing the return of their glass bottles to be washed, refilled, and resold. In 2001, for example, over 6 million tons of aluminum, glass, and plastic soft drink and beer containers were wasted in the United States -- sent to landfills and incinerators, and littered along our nation's roads, parks, and beaches. If these bottles and cans had been recycled instead, we could have saved the energy equivalent of 30 million barrels of crude oil, reduced greenhouse gas emissions by 4.5 million tons, and saved untold millions of dollars in cleanup costs. Comparisons between states with bottle bills and those with curbside recycling programs reveal more containers are recycled in states that have a bottle bill law on the books. In addition to reducing the burden on landfills, bottle bills can create jobs and save taxpayers money. For more information on how your state can enact a bottle bill, visit: http://www.serconline.org/bottlebill/index.html.
back to top
 
NJ Anti-Sprawl Rule Delayed to Close Loophole (The Star-Ledger, 9/3)
Part of New Jersey Governor James McGreevey's "war on sprawl" will be delayed at least a year for revisions and further public comment. The new rule was written to limit growth and decrease water pollution by restricting development near high-quality water bodies and requiring lots to be water-permeable. The rule was originally expected to take effect this summer, but state officials were alerted to a potential loophole by builders' association lobbyists pushing for broad exemptions. The questionable language, in the grandfathering clause, could be interpreted to mean that developments with preliminary local approval before the rule took effect -- a relatively easy step -- were exempt. The clause has since been rewritten to require developments to have one of four more strict state permits for building near water, in addition to local approval, in order to qualify for exemption. Local environmentalists support the revised rule, but want it to take effect more quickly. Some have also expressed concern that the grandfathering clause, even after being strengthened, would exempt too many pending developments. The state Department of Environmental Protection Commissioner, Bradley Campbell, has called the rule "as strict an approach we can take without repealing existing permits and applying the rule retroactively, which we don't think we could defend in court." For more information on the effects of sprawl, visit: http://www.serconline.org/sprawl/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top 
 
ALEC's Resolution on Climate Change (Occasionally SERC will be profiling model legislation developed by ALEC as part of the ALEC Bill Watch Series.)
Alarmed by a flurry of state legislative activity addressing the serious problem of global warming, the corporate-funded American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) drafted model legislation entitled "State Responses to Kyoto Climate Change Protocol" in 1998 and a "General Resolution on Climate Change" in July 2003. The similar model bills both prohibit "the proposal or promulgation of state regulations intended to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases, prior to [federal] ratification of the Kyoto climate change protocol... and enactment of implementing legislation." In support of its global warming bills, ALEC makes unsubstantiated (and disproved) claims, including that the Kyoto Protocol unfairly burdens developed countries and that enactment of policies to meet emissions reduction targets would harm the economy. With regard to economic repercussions, two comprehensive U.S. government analyses predicted the impact of energy efficiency and renewable energy policies on the economy to be minimal or positive. Moreover, a number of non-governmental studies have reported that the production of energy from renewable sources employs more people than that from coal. ALEC's two global warming bills use bad science, misleading and selective reporting, and a special interest bias to block states from taking action on one of the most important environmental issues today. In the words of the National Academy of Sciences, climate change is real, in large part due to human activities, and likely to have "large, abrupt, and unwelcome" effects. ALEC should stop contributing to the problem with its own hot air.
back to top 
 
Colorado Study Confirms Deer-to-Deer Spread of CWD (Milwaukee Journal Sentinel 9/3)
A new study by Beth Williams and Michael Miller found that chronic wasting disease (CWD) spreads most quickly when deer are kept in close contact with each other. The study also disproved the notion that CWD might be transmitted from mother to unborn offspring. This clarification supports a ban on baiting and feeding deer and highlights the risk of disease transmission in game farms. The study did not say how the fatal brain disease was spread, although contact with bodily secretions is the most likely route. For more information on how your state can prevent the spread of CWD, visit: http://www.serconline.org/CWD/index.html.
back to top
 
Chittenden County, Vermont Launches 'No Idling Campaign' (Vermont Free Press 9/2)
Several school districts are asking school bus and parent drivers to switch off engines while waiting outside school to reduce exhaust emissions that harm students' health and the environment. The program is sponsored by the American Lung Association and 10% Challenge, a nonprofit group working to cut local greenhouse gas emissions by 10% by 2010. All other New England states already have 'no idling' policies in place. Exhaust fumes contribute to global warming and can trigger severe asthma attacks in addition to longer-term health problems. "It's a small piece; it's a statement," said Lyman Anderson, Burlington School District superintendent. "By itself it's not going to save the world, but our nine schools have the potential to make an impact." To find out more about children's health risks associated with vehicle emissions, visit http://www.serconline.org/schoolbus/index.html.
back to top
 
WI Pushes for Construction Waste Recycling (Milwaukee Journal Sentinel 8/29)
A state study found that construction and demolition debris, such as wood, drywall, and carpeting, account for 30% of landfills. To extend the life span of landfills, nonprofits and the Department of Natural Resources are trying to raise awareness about convenient and cost-saving recycling opportunities. Although much of construction material can be recycled, it is not banned from landfills. WasteCap Wisconsin Inc. is overseeing recycling efforts of a 400,000-square-foot arts complex in Madison that required razing four buildings. Jenna Kunde, Executive Director of that organization, said a number of recycling opportunities exist, including grinding up drywall for agricultural fertilization, lumber scraps for mulch, carpets for backing, and ceiling tiles for new ceiling tiles. In addition, windows, doors, plumbing fixtures, and other surplus items can be directly reused.
back to top
 
Mourning Doves under Fire in Midwest (Lansing State Journal, 9/5)
The same week that the first Wisconsin mourning dove hunt since 1918 opened, debate in Michigan about whether to add the bird to the state's list of game species heated up. Last month, State Representative Susan Tabor introduced a bill to legalize mourning dove hunting in Michigan, saying the change would bring in revenue for the state and benefit hunters. The Michigan United Conservation Clubs, which has pushed for a mourning dove hunt for 20 years, is encouraging sportsmen to contact their legislators. On the other side, the Songbird Protection Coalition has put up a billboard and a website (http://www.savethedoves.org/) and is e-mailing anti-hunt alerts to thousands of people. In 2000, legislation declaring mourning doves a game species passed the House but failed by one vote in the Senate. Federal officials estimate that there are 400 million mourning doves in North America, including 4 million in Michigan. Governor Jennifer Granholm, who has noted widespread public opposition to a mourning dove hunt, said she doubted that the new effort would succeed.
back to top
 
Inter-State Summit on Missouri River Set (Billings Gazette, 9/5)
Governors from at least four states will soon meet to discuss issues surrounding the management of the Missouri River. Governors from North Dakota, Nebraska, and Kansas will join the hosting South Dakota governor for the September 24th summit at Dakota Dunes. They may also be joined by the governors of Iowa and Missouri; Montana is sending the director of its Department of Natural Resources and Conservation. The states will discuss their disagreements over the management of Missouri River water levels. Upstream states have complained that too much water is released through dams in South Dakota, North Dakota, and Montana during the spring and summer. Downstream states say the higher water levels are needed near where the Missouri and Mississippi rivers meet to support barge traffic, city water supplies, and other uses.
back to top
 
Trend Shows City Centers Changing (Augusta Chronicle 9/1)
A concept called new urbanism is growing in popularity in response to the decline of many downtowns during the least 60 years. New urbanism focuses on a set of principles that include walkable, mixed-use neighborhoods allowing residents to fulfill most of their daily needs without leaving the general area. The new-urbanism model calls for downtowns that are cultural and entertainment centers; but, this doesn't mean traditional downtown merchants can't thrive under the city model. Even though citizens appear to be more content living in suburbs while cities rebuild themselves, a recent survey indicates that demands for dense, walkable neighborhoods will increase in the coming decade. According to the 2000 U.S. Census, 24 of the nation's 280 metropolitan areas lost population between 1990 and 2000. With this exodus from the cities came a decline in employment opportunities which, in turn, led to a decline in the level and quality of city services and the further degradation of downtown areas. For more information on how your state can embrace community revitalization, visit: http://www.serconline.org/community/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top
 
Chesapeake Bay Foundation Seeks Binding Compact from Governors (Greenwire 9/5)
The Chesapeake Bay Foundation is asking the governors of Maryland, Virginia, and Pennsylvania to agree to a binding compact for regulating releases of nitrogen and other pollutants into the Chesapeake Bay, arguing that promised reductions have not been met under a widely touted voluntary agreement between the states, the federal government, industry, and environmentalists. The compact would focus on reducing three primary pollutants -- nitrogen, phosphorous, and sediment. The foundation believes this can be achieved by incorporating nitrogen discharge limits into clean water permits, and including specific curbs on the three pollutants in farm nutrient management plans and state clean air plans. Although an executive council exists and a voluntary agreement was entered into three years ago pledging to meet certain water quality standards by 2010, little progress appears to have been made. Officials have already failed to reduce nitrogen standards by voluntary agreements and this summer high nitrogen levels have caused the largest 'dead zone' in recent memory.
back to top
 
Florida Not Collecting Polluter Fines (ENS 9/4)
The Florida Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (FPEER) released a report this week detailing the failure of the state to collect fines from polluters. The report indicates a severe decline in the collection of civil penalties, and notes one of the largest declines occurred in collecting from corporate polluters, based on information from the DEP Office of General Counsel. Since 1987, the disparity between penalties assessed and penalties collected appears to have cost the state over $45 million. In addition to pulling back on collecting fines, it appears fewer penalties are also being assessed. According to FPEER director Jerry Phillips, "Forty-five million dollars would have gone a long way toward cleaning up the state's pollution." For more information on how your state can prevent a similar situation, visit: http://www.serconline.org/enforce/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top
 
Western States Brace for West Nile Virus (CNN.com 9/5)
As the summer season winds down, western states are beginning to prepare for next summer's outbreak of West Nile virus as it continues its westward movement. In Colorado, 1,051 people were infected, with 16 individuals dying as a result of contracting the virus. The Centers for Disease Control reported last week that West Nile virus activity has again doubled, with 34 states reporting a total of 1,442 cases and 21 deaths. Officials anticipate that Arizona, western Colorado, Idaho, and Utah will be hit next year by the virus, with it potentially reaching California by 2005. Arizona officials report they have been preparing for years and are concerned due to the state's large population of elderly individuals, while Utah has placed billboards up to remind people of the dangers of the virus. For more information on what states have done in response to the West Nile virus, visit: http://www.serconline.org/westNile.html.
back to top

For more information about SERC, or to use our services, contact our national headquarters at:
State Environmental Resource Center
106 East Doty Street, Suite 200 § Madison, Wisconsin 53703
Phone: 608-252-9800 § Fax: 608-252-9828
Email: info@serconline.org